Skip to Main Content

Student Name: __________________________

Faculty Grader: _________________________

| Download (.pdf) | Print

 

Total

Outcome Met

100%

**

50%

Outcome Not Met

0%

Outcome 1 (10 pts)

 

Contained all pertinent information

 

10 pts

The assignment contained background, methods, statistical analysis, results, author’s conclusion, independent critiques, and discussion.

5 pts

The assignment did not contain 1–2 necessary sections, or sections were not of adequate quality.

0 pts

The assignment did not contain 3–4 necessary sections or sections were not of adequate quality.

Outcome 2 (15 pts)

 

Identify strengths of article

 

15 pts

The assignment identified two thoughtful strengths of the article.

8 pts

The assignment identified one thoughtful strength of the article.

0 pts

The assignment did not identify any thoughtful strengths of the article.

Outcome 3 (15 pts)

 

Identify weakness of the article

 

15 pts

The assignment identified a reasonable weakness of the article.

8 pts

The assignment identified a trivial weakness of the article.

0 pts

The assignment did not identify any weakness of the article.

Outcome 4 (5 pts)

 

State conclusion/implication

 

5 pts

The assignment clearly stated an independent conclusion/implication.

3 pts

N/A

0 pts

The assignment restated author’s conclusions or results without any independent thoughts.

Outcome 5 (10 pts)

 

Appropriate attributions given

 

10 pts

The assignment was fully referenced, included no direct quotes or plagiarized information.

5 pts

The assignment contained minimal unreferenced information, direct quotes, or plagiarized information.

0 pts

The assignment contained multiple unreferenced statements, contained more than 1 sentence that was directly quoted, or contained plagiarized information.

Outcome 6 (10 pts)

 

Reference formatting

 

10 pts

All references listed were in a format consistent with AMA.

5 pts

References listed were not consistent with AMA in 1 place.

0 pts

References listed were not consistent with AMA in greater than 2 places.

Outcome 7 (5 pts)

 

Provide a concise handout

 

5 pts

The handout was shorter than 1 page front/back in length, including references [Times New Roman, at least 10-point font].

0 pts

N/A

0 pts

The handout was longer than 1 page front/back in length, including references [Times New Roman, at least 10-point font].

Outcome 8 (10 pts)

 

Avoid significant grammar and spelling errors in writing

 

10 pts

The assignment contained less than 5 spelling or grammatical errors.

5 pts

The assignment contained 5–10 spelling or grammatical errors.

0 pts

The assignment contained more than 10 spelling or grammatical errors.

Handout Total Score

/80

 

 

 

| Download (.pdf) | Print

 

Total

Outcome Met

100%

**

50%

Outcome Not Met

0%

Outcome 9 (10 pts)

Presentation

 

10 pts

Presenter faced audience

Good eye contact

Dressed professionally

Presentation <8 minutes

Answered 1 question correctly

5 pts

The presenter did not do 1–2 necessary components.

0 pts

The presenter did not do 3–4 necessary components.

Outcome 10 (10...

Pop-up div Successfully Displayed

This div only appears when the trigger link is hovered over. Otherwise it is hidden from view.